Latest Posts

Tin Can Update — Looking Rusty

rusty tin can

Hello? Hello?  Is anybody out there using Tin Can?

I’ve been holding this rusty Tin Can for over a year and starting to feel a little silly that I might have been taken in by the hype.  In our Top 12 ASTD 2014 Take-A-Ways post last month,  we commented on how the Tin Can hype seemed to be waning in comparison to last year.  We wanted to dig further and find out “why” and also compile case study examples of how organizations were using Tin Can.  We were surprised at what we found.  Nothing.

Is Your Tin Can Rusty?

Tin Can or the Experience API is the new content/elearning standard touted as the successor to SCORM.  Tin Can simplifies the tracking and recording of any learning event – no matter how informal or non-traditional making it easier to use and less limiting than SCORM.

Yeh!  That should be good for something!  Something really great that we can’t do already with our LMS!

Hmmm….wait a minute, currently in LMS solutions, you can track the completion of just about any learning event from instructor led, virtual classroom, eLearning, Word, Power Point, videos, podcasts, documents, web pages, Sharepoint docs, wikis, blogs, external learning events, college classes, conferences and much, much more.  The better LMSs can monitor your social LMS activities such as how many times you comment, share, answer questions or interact and set interaction thresholds for social event completion or gamification award status.   LMS solutions have figured out how to do this from both a desktop and mobile experience.   That’s some pretty minute tracking.

So what else can Tin Can do that is useful to training and development professionals?  Well, I heard you can track even more informal things like reading a book, watching a movie, going to a conference, taking notes, taking a hike or learning to tango.  Wait, many LMS solutions can do all this too.

I read that Tin Can can track social interactions happening in other systems and pass it back to the LMS – that might be handy if anybody really wanted to report on that.  Seriously, is there any other measurable information that we are missing that matters?  Will all the informal stuff being formalized on a user record really help anyone?

As you can see, I’m struggling to understand the business application of this rusty Tin Can.  As an instructional technologist, I think it is cool.  As a LMS consultant helping organizations choose LMS systems –meaningless clutter.

At Talented Learning we reviewed about 25 of the world’s top LMS solutions in the last few months and asked almost every LMS vendor about their current level of Tin Can support and examples of clients using it.   Here is what we found:

Most LMSs say they support Tin Can or will support it to some minimal degree in the future.  All agree they have to have it from a marketing standpoint, but few espouse it or think the industry really needs it.  We collected only one real life example (verbal only) of a customer using it to take and pass notes.  One.  We collected countless vendor examples of “how you could use it.”

This couldn’t be all hype that will fade away –is it?  The industry didn’t just spend millions of dollars collectively for a feature set no one wants to use –did they?  This doesn’t mean that training departments and executives might not care if you answered a question on a blog or posted a comment –does it?

We’re sure those Tin Can examples are out there and we’re just being obtuse — help us help others and send us your Tin Can story!

Send Us Your Story!  How Do You Use Tin Can?

PLEASE —  contact us with your real life Tin Can success, case studies, news articles,  relevant links or anything to show us Tin Can is being used and valued.  We’ll consolidate all the information in a non-biased way and blog the results!  Hopefully, we’ll find some great working stories and we’ll all learn something —

Is anyone out there using Tin Can?  Hello?  Hello?

Now Available:  LMS Almanac:  Corporate Edition

It’s here folks and it is good.  The LMS Almanac:  Corporate Edition 2016 will help LMS buyers cut through all the fluff in the industry and get a true view of what is going on.   Deep detail and statistics about the corporate LMS market trends, 75 vendor profiles, 100+ comparison graphics and charts, , learning, tech dictionary and more.   If you are looking for an LMS for your employees, channel partners or customers, this report is vital to helping you quickly qualify vendors and find the best for you.

John Leh
About John Leh (131 Articles)
John Leh is CEO and Lead Analyst at Talented Learning, LLC. Named one of the Top 20 Global Elearning Movers and Shakers of 2017, John is a fiercely independent LMS selection consultant and blogger who helps organizations develop and implement technology strategies – primarily for the extended enterprise. John's advice is based on 20 years of industry experience, having served as a trusted LMS selection and sales adviser to more than 100 learning organizations with a total technology spend of more than $65 million. He helps organizations define their business case, identify requirements, short-list vendors, write and manage RFPs and negotiate a great deal. You can connect with John on Twitter at @JohnLeh or on LinkedIn.

3 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. The Hidden Cost of Qualifying LMS Vendors | Talented Learning
  2. LMS Reviews: Brightwave Tessello - Talented Learning
  3. LMS Review: Brightwave Tessello - Talented Learning

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.