Learning management systems didn’t die. They evolved, and today we recognize them.
Brief LMS History
Corporate LMSs were invented almost 30 years ago to manage and report on the training and compliance of their employees and contractors. They were expensive to purchase, implement, maintain, host, upgrade and replace. Much of the investment was upfront and only the largest companies or companies with the most compliance risk exposure could afford an LMS.
Every LMS tried to be all things to all types of customers in all industries. The field of competitors for the first 15 years or so was limited to an evolving 12-15 viable yet dismally average, bloated solutions.
The LMS market started changing after the dot com bust in 2001. LMS companies (and many software companies) were top heavy, poorly run organizations and the strong gobbled up the weak. A steady flurry of acquisitions disrupted customers’ lives but never the market as a whole. Innovation was stagnant and most vendor effort was invested in stealing customers from one another.
Starting around 2010, the market began changing again. LMS and performance management companies started merging and then the big HR/talent players acquired them. SAP acquired SuccessFactors who had acquired Plateau. Oracle acquired Taleo who had acquired Learn.com and the list goes on. LMS innovation was stifled yet again and innumerable customers became lost in the bureaucracy of behemoth software companies.
Cloud to the Rescue
To save the day the cloud was invented and with it the significant fiscal barriers of entry for new LMS providers were removed. The cloud enables new LMS vendors to create and support one product that all customers use providing economies of scale in research, customer support and required investment capital. Over the last five years, new LMS companies have poured into the marketplace filling an obvious need of customer service and targeted business solutions. The cloud LMSs provide learning management to the masses.
Cloud LMS solutions are easy-to-use, modern, mobile, social and incredibly affordable. Now small businesses and even individuals can easily and rapidly get going. Many cloud LMSs have “free trials” that provide instant access to their solution directly from their website providing the opportunity to test out use cases.
The LMS industry in 2015 now has hundreds and hundreds of viable vendor solutions.
The good news is there is an LMS for every need, industry and budget. The bad news is there is an LMS for every need, industry and budget. It costs at least$1500 for an organization to qualify a LMS vendor and even figuring out where to start the process makes calculus seem easy.
Our LMS Research and Methodology
We founded Talented Learning, an independent learning technology research firm, to figure it all out for buyers and sellers. Our mission is to map the LMS world. We’ve spent the last two years going LMS vendor by LMS vendor and identifying who they are, what they do, who they sell to and why they are unique.
We read the publicly available information, talk directly with vendor executives, receive product briefings, attend deep-dive product demonstrations, test-drive learning applications and even interview customers. We ask vendors to respond to standardized, in-depth surveys that focus on hundreds of business, technical and functional data points. In the last 20 months, we have reviewed 103 LMSs.
We also have the advantage of running the LMS selection process for dozens of buyers, and have broad access to vendor data, customer stories and experiences. Prior to co-founding Talented Learning, I sold LMSs for 13 years and generated over $50,000,000 in revenue. All of this experience and research was factored into our Talented Learning 2015 LMS Vendor Award rankings and market categorization.
We didn’t take this task lightly. Here are the best of the LMS best.
The 2015 Talented Learning LMS Vendor Award Winners
Types of LMSs in 2015
Before releasing any rankings or awards, we first needed to determine what types of LMSs existed in the marketplace so that the awards were relevant and helpful to LMS buyers.
We discovered that the LMS marketplace is made up of 4 broad types of LMS including corporate, academic, continuing education and association LMSs. All four groups share some functionality but contain special functionality and experience not required in the other areas.
The corporate LMS market is further fractured into LMSs that focus on employee compliance, talent management, channel (partner, dealer or franchise) and customers learning applications. Some corporate LMSs can do it all (all-purpose corporate LMSs) but many focus on just employee or external applications.
The hottest area of innovation in all groups are the ecommerce features and functions to support sale of content to their audiences – also called extended enterprise learning. Corporations are selling content and certifications to their channel partners and customers. Academic institutions are selling college courses to remote global audiences. Associations are selling content to their members and continuing education training providers are selling content to anyone. Continuing education, associations and universities are all selling their content to corporations.
And without further ado, here are the best of the best LMS vendors in the world in 11 categories.
All LMS vendors in this category are capable and focused on supporting all aspects of the learning inside and outside an organization. Vendors are able to be used for any combination of employees, channel, dealers, partners, customers and prospects. All-purpose corporate LMSs have considerable administrative configuration, domain and audience segmentation, globalization, ecommerce, ILT management, online learning management, reporting and integration capabilities.
BEST CHANNEL & PARTNER LMS
If an organization educates and certifies their external sales channel, they will experience increased sales, new streams of revenue and increased customer satisfaction. Every time. All LMS vendors on this list actively promote channel learning on their website with product offerings, case studies, webinars, and client testimonials.
The nominated solutions have varying degrees of sophistication in core channel functionality including domain segmentation, e-commerce, social learning, globalization, broad content support, mobile readiness and ease of use. Channel & partner LMSs have strong integration and shared workflow capabilities with dealer management, incentive management, ecommerce, order fulfillment, CRM and ERPs. The vendors on this list (and other award categories) range from self-service free-trial LMSs to comprehensive heavy-duty enterprise-class solution providers.
BEST CUSTOMER LMS
Most LMS vendors will say they are good for customers, but true customer LMSs are unique. Customer LMSs could be called “Learning Marketing Systems” because there is a deep level capability that typically resides in marketing – not training departments. Customer LMSs have to be super easy to use for customers and resemble Facebook more than a database.
Integration with CRM software like Salesforce.com or a Dynamics allows any customer activity such as purchase, renewal, attending a webinar, downloading a paper to trigger the push of intelligent recommendations of learning events. Trained customers buy more over time and are more satisfied and customer LMSs make it happen. Here are the top customer LMSs in the world:
BEST EMPLOYEE COMPLIANCE LMS
You can’t get away from where LMSs started. Employee and contractor compliance is a big problem for many organizations. Federal and state and local jurisdictions enact training, safety and harassment regulations and then audit for compliance. Non-compliance results in penalties and fines. The more jurisdictions an organization does business within, the bigger the compliance management challenges they have.
Industries such as pharmaceutical, biomedical, manufacturers, transportation, energy, financial, retail and many others are all required to deliver mandatory compliance training and be ready to prove it to auditors at any time. Compliance LMSs are admin focused and have skills, competencies, audit trails, electronic signatures, strong ILT management, facility and resource management, broad content support and powerhouse reporting. Our choices for the world’s best compliance LMS are:
BEST EMPLOYEE DEVELOPMENT LMS
The talent LMSs used to be the tier one LMSs before they got acquired by the big HR software companies. Talent LMSs are integrated into broader HR and talent suites of products including recruiting, succession, goals, performance, time, payroll and provide a higher level of value – to progressive organizations – than stand alone employee compliance LMSs. Talent LMSs support all flavors of employee use cases including career development, leadership development and onboarding where the most productive workflows will tap into performance management, succession and other areas of talent management. Data is shared from the talent and learning modules that effect content recommendations, skill and competency acquisition, succession planning and performance reviews. With increased complexity of workflow comes more administrative burden, time to implement and cost but also a higher return on investment. The world’s best talent LMS solution are:
- CD2 Learning
- Together JAZZ (a Skylab Italia Solution)
BEST ACADEMIC LMS
The academic LMS market is very distinct from the others. K-12, vocational and higher education institutions still need a special system to manage students, classes, teachers and the interactions between them. What is interesting is the technique and functionality required to train students by providing instructors the tools to assemble content, video record their sessions, introduce assignments, readings, homework, formal online learning, massive open online courses and social learning has been morphing into corporate, association and continuing education LMSs types. At the same time, the development of ecommerce capabilities to attract non-captured student learners globally and sell content has been the big recent innovation in academic LMSs learned from the other types of LMSs. Our choices for the best academic LMS are:
BEST CONTINUING EDUCATION LMS
Continuing education LMSs are targeting training companies of all types. Countless for-profit training companies create, deliver and manage accredited content for certain industries and regions in a CE LMS. Whether they’re traditional training companies with instructors, brick and mortar facilities or whether they are new school training companies focused purely on ecommerce and online content. The products in this group look like Amazon or Best Buy and they have deep B2B and B2C e-commerce capability and a strategic ability to dynamically group users for target marketing and promotions.
Traditional training management, CRM integration, virtual classrooms (integrated or native), ecommerce, sales tax management, complex CEU management, accreditation body integration are just some of the advanced feature sets available and required to be on this list. There are quite a few organizations that we think are really good in this category.
BEST ASSOCIATION LMS
The association LMS space is extremely specialized, and is experiencing explosive growth and innovation. With a cloud LMS, any association of any size or wealth can now support education initiatives with sophisticated learning technology. Selling accredited professional education content to members and managing all related learning activities generates non-dues revenue — and this is big business. Many association LMS vendors entered the space as event planners for annual association trade shows. These events are packed with education sessions that needed to be coordinated, managed and recorded, so vendors started customizing LMSs to fit that precise need.
Many corporate LMS providers have tried to capitalize on association needs, but their employee-focused product logic and positioning are lacking or irrelevant. Association LMSs require tight integration with association management systems (AMSs), B2B and B2C ecommerce, globalization, audience segmentation, mobile responsiveness, usable social learning capabilities, virtual classrooms, webcasting tools, podcast support, and event management features. They are also designed with ease of use in mind for a wide range of user types. This list was the most difficult to rank because there are so many excellent choices. Not surprisingly, we ended up with a four-way tie for second place. The best association LMS vendors in the world are:
BEST LMS THOUGHT LEADERS
Part of the Talented Learning research process is to follow all LMS vendors on social media. We monitor and read all their posts, content, interviews, research papers and case studies they promote. We attend their webinars. As LMS learning technology bloggers ourselves, we appreciate the work and dedication it takes to crank out good content.
Some vendors are silent, some just promote their own products but a select few are trying to define the industry and move it forward for all. They give buyers tools and knowledge to buy better and smarter – even if it means they might buy another system. And so, here are who we think are the top 10 LMS thought leaders across the world…
- Growth Engineering
- Peach New Media
- Brightwave tessello
BEST LMS DEMONSTRATOR
Being an LMS demonstrator is tough. They are the hero when they win and the zero when they lose. They are expected to deliver an impactful demonstration every time and do it better than the other 10 organizations the buyer is evaluating. LMS demonstrators are in hot demand in the industry. We can place a good demonstrator yesterday. Demonstrators not only have to understand learning, the LMS and business objectives, but demo in a humorous, engaging way that is tailored to the audience. Here are the best we’ve met:
- Caleb Johnson, Expertus
- Caoimhín Gillespie, LearnUpon
- Kelley Shirazi Lunceford, Bluevolt
- Ezra Wolfe, EthosCE
- Meg Stevenson, tessello
- Sean McCarthy, SumTotal
- Tamer Ali, YM Learning
LMS SALES STAR
Last but not least… An LMS sales job is increasingly difficult especially with the recent explosion in competition. There are so many self-inflicted mistakes salespeople make time and again in the sales process. In our role as analysts and LMS buyer consultants, we get to meet a ton of LMS sales people from around the world and see them sell in action.
The best LMS salespeople listen more than they sell, solve problems, are super responsive, excellent writers, better presenters and can navigate a long winding sales cycle. We don’t know if the following salespeople are the best in the world, but they are the best we have encountered.
- Tom Bronikowski , Expertus
- Travis Hudelson, Saba
- Kelley Shirazi Lunceford, BlueVolt
- Dan Medakovic, Blatant Absorb LMS
- Tim McDonnell, SumTotal Systems
- Jocelyn Fielding, Blue Sky Broadcast
- Meg Stevenson, tessello
- Caleb Johnson, Expertus
- Jim Lynch, Accord LMS
Congratulations to all named winners –you deserve the recognition! The LMS market is thriving, morphing, evolving and expanding into all areas of selling content. This is great news for everyone including buyers, sellers and anyone involved in creating content.
Thanks for reading!
Replay the 2015 LMS Awards Ceremony Webinar On Demand!
Want to learn more about these vendors, LMS categories and market trends? Tune into our webinar recording of our recent 2015 Talented Learning LMS Vendor Awards Ceremony by filling out the form below.