I’ve done a lot of work with associations and continuing education in my past career as LMS sales guy but nothing compared to the last 6 months helping five separate national member organizations in five industries (legal, medical, financial, transportation and public sector) define their requirements and find the best LMS for them. What struck me was how similar yet different each industry approaches continuing education and the resulting diverse learning technology requirements.
I reviewed 81 LMS solutions in the last 18 months. LMS providers new and old will readily tell you that their systems can track continuing education units (CEU) or credits. However, the continuing education capability, suitability and experience of the LMS vendors varies widely. Continuing education functionality is a big area of vendor differentiation and an easy place for a buyer to make a poor selection decision if you are not careful.
In the coming months I’m going to dig deep into defining the continuing education industry, learning technology requirements and identifying the specialized LMS vendors that can meet the challenge. If you are in the continuing education or extended enterprise world, you are going to love it, for the rest, I’ll try and make it interesting. For example, check out and register our next webinar on June 4th Best Practices Managing Complex CEUs.
What is Continuing Education and CEU?
Continuing education is broadly defined as training provided to adults after they have left the formal education process. It can be informal like taking a Lynda.com course online or completing a MOOC or more formal like earning your Project Management Professional certificate or maintaining a professional degree or educational certificate.
In 1970, the International Association for Continuing Education (IACET), accredited by the American National Standards Institute, set the standard for continuing education units (CEU) and quantified 1 CEU = 10 hours of learning. However, with the evolution of self-paced eLearning many industries have simplified to 1 CEU = 1 hour of study. Though in some industries like accounting and legal 1 CEU = 50 minutes of instruction.
How Big Is the Continuing Education Market?
According to a US Census Bureau report published in 2014, there are 46 million U.S. adults (25% of adult population) that hold educational credentials other than formal college degrees and are thus engaged in formal continuing education activities. This number does not include the millions upon millions of adults consuming continuing education for non-certificate purposes. If each of those 46 million learners is required to take 10 hours of continuing education a year (conservative estimate) that translates to almost a half a billion hours of content consumed per year!
A 2015 report from the Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce titled “College Is Just the Beginning” asserts certifications, apprenticeships, and other workforce training comprise $47 billion of annual U.S. spending on formal training.
By comparison, Josh Bersin, Principal of Bersin by Delliotte estimates the LMS market to be around $2.5 billion in a 2014 Forbes article. Seems like the LMS market should be taking a bigger piece of the $47 Billion CE pie but I have found the complex continuing education functional and business workflow requirements are tough to meet for 90% of vendors and are a nightmare to manage manually. Here are some examples.
The Administrative Nightmare Continuing Education for Accountants
Accounting firms, accountants and providers of CPEs (CEUs for accountants) need an LMS that manages a complex set of CEU conditions.
What it takes to maintain a professional license or certification, however, is unique from state to state. For example, in Alaska, certified public accountants must complete four hours of instruction on Alaska-specific ethics, statutes and regulations. In Ohio, the ethics requirement is three hours. If you are an accountant licensed in both states then the administrative challenges multiply. If you manage continuing education for an accounting firm with accountants in 25 states who are licensed in multiple states, you are a saint.
In the accounting industry, most accounting firms set up a National Association of State Boards of Accountancy (NASBA) license and grant continuing professional education (CPE) credit based on the NASBA standards, rather than maintain the complex CPE rules of each state.
LearnLive Technologies, which is a compliance software application owned by Thomson Reuters, automatically maps NASBA CPE credit to each state jurisdiction. An LMS that can regularly feed the NASBA CPE credits a learner earns plays a critical role in helping organizations automate the steps of mapping and reporting of CPE renewal compliance.
A key for training directors is having an LMS that includes the ability to easily integrate with any other software in an organization’s ecosystem including CPE mapping tools, practice management software, human resource information system, single sign on, CEU tracking in another system, surveys and assessment engines. The LMS will then share data with these systems eliminating manual administrative intervention.
The Even Worse Nightmare of Continuing Medical Education
Healthcare continuing medical education takes it to a new level. There are only a handful of different types of accountants but hundreds of types of doctors, nurses, surgeons, dentists, pharmacists and technical staff that have need mandatory continuing medical education (CME) to satisfy their maintenance of credit (MOC) requirements for each specialty or certificate they hold.
Within each state, the requirements for each medical specialty also varies. CME and CPE (pharmacists) are among the most complex from a management perspective. Licensing, regulations, accreditations, tracking and management challenges are a herculean administrative task. At hospitals, entire departments are formed to manage the maze of healthcare continuing education. It’s no less complicated for the certifying organizations that have to sort out which CE to accept from other entities.
In healthcare, there is not one system that tracks all CME for everyone, so depending on how ingenious organizations are, there is a wide disparity on the amount of manual administration time and money required.
The complexities of CEU challenge even the best LMS vendors. To truly manage CLE or continuing education for accountants, doctors or lawyers, an LMS should do more than award a single CEU value and single CEU type. Instead, the LMS should offer a potentially unlimited number of CEU values and CEU types per curriculum record. The CEU value and CEU type that a user earns must be based on where the learner is licensed to truly help all concerned.
Better managing the complexities of professional continuing education requires centralizing CE processes and integration with other systems and a serious hard look at all your business processes. An end state for everyone touching professional CE would be knowing in real-time the total amount and type of credits needed and a historical record of what’s been learned.
Thanks for reading!
Are you Shopping for a CEU LMS?
Fill out the form below to schedule a complimentary consultation call with myself, John Leh.
Want to Learn More about Complex CEUs?
Check out the webinar recording “Best Practices Managing Complex CEUs” John Leh, CEO of Talented Learning and Bill Snowdon, CTO of eLogic Learning outline the business and technical challenges facing organizations that manage or sell continuing education. In this session you will learn:
• Statistics and size of continuing education market
• Professions requiring most continuing education
• Today’s tools and technologies for managing CEUs, CMEs, CLEs and more
• Levels of CEU support from LMS solutions
• Question and Answer